Institutional Mechanisms for the AdvancementI.R.I
Introduction
Background
The political system of Iran before revolution has not been able to attract women’s
participation in public participation and governmental mechanisms and only a limited
number of women connected to the king’s family were recruited in governmental
structures. Consequently, only elite and intellectual women were recruited in the
governmental structure and improving women’s life was limited to this stage.
After Islamic Revolution in Iran and extensive public participation of women from
all social spectrums - that were marginalized before- in political changes; promotion
of social capitals, women were able to enter decision-making.
Electing a scientist woman in the Expert Assembly of the Constitution and presence
of women in the Parliament, powerful political parties and guardian forces; the first
rays of women’s participation in decision-making and planning were sin.
After the imposed war and entering the reconstruction period; women’s organizations
were formed and gender sensitive approaches were adopted.
Since the beginning of 90s, women’s mechanisms were established by the efforts of
women involved in governmental organizations and university. The first national
supreme organization formed after the Islamic Revolution, was Women’s
Department of Presidency Office and has offices in all ministries as consultant to
the minister. This mechanism gradually expanded and by a change in name became
the Center for Women’s Participation in 1997 to do programming and supervise
gender budgets in the third national development plan at governmental levels.
The Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran
Article 21
The government must ensure the rights of women in all respects, in conformity
with Islamic criteria,
Vision:
The 20-year Vision of the country:
A society enjoying health, welfare, food security, social security, equal opportunities,
proper distribution of income, strong family structure, far from poverty, corruption,
discrimination and benefiting an appropriate environment.
Note: Reinforcing national organizations for women’s development is a necessity for realization of
such perspective.
Charter of Women’s Rights and Responsibilities
67. Right to exchange creative cultural information and communications at the
national and international levels
66. Women’s right to establish and manage cultural-arts centers and organizations
in order to train responsible women and women specialists to improve their cultural
activities
70. Right to partake in policymaking, legislation, execution and supervision relating
to cultural affairs, particularly, women’s issues
Institutional Mechanisms for the Advancement of Women
101
National Beijing+10 Report ofthe Communication Network of
Women's NGOs of the I.R.I
Current Situation and Achievements
Create or Strengthen National Mechanisms for Advancement of
Women
H.1 CREATE OR STRENGTHEN NATIONAL MACHINERIES AND
OTHER GOVERNMETNAL BODIES
Three main indicators for realization of this goal are as follows:
Presence of a national system for gender mainstreaming
Presence of focal points within the governmental structure
Gender-sensitive training for governmental authorities and staff
In assessing the first indicator, presence of two important institutions in government,
the Presidential Center for Women’s Participation and Social and Cultural
Council of Women, a sub-group to the Supreme Council of the Cultural Revolution,
presence of a Bureau to Support Women and Children’s Rights in the Judiciary
structure and Women’s Faction in the Parliament show that the existence of mechanisms
in three branches of the country. Evaluating activities of the Center for
Women’s Participation and the Social and Cultural Council of Women shows that
these two can be the most fundamental mechanisms for women’s development in
the country, since according to the Beijing statement, these organizations should
have clear and defined responsibilities and power and the main factors are: sufficient
resources, power and competence to influence policies and reviewing laws.
This organization should analyze policies and strategies and has the responsibility
of supporting, communicating, coordinating and monitoring the implementation
process.
Center forWomen’s Participation
The Center for Women’s Participation, previously named as Department of
Women’s Affairs of Presidency Office was promoted to the Center for Women’s
Participation at 1997 and started its activities holding a defined agenda for increasing
women’s participation at various arenas of high rank decision making and
reporting to senior authorities (such as Supreme Leader, President and Islamic
Parliament). Advisor to the President is the head of the Center though is not holding
a minister title but she can be continually present in meetings.
Center for Women’s Participation had a special attention to the NGOs, a trend that
started years before during the formation of the Department of Women’s Affairs.
Quantitative growth can be observed among women’s NGOs but there are not
enough proves to say that this growth is due to implementation of Article 158 of
Third Development Plan or other social factors have also been involved and influenced
the growth of these organizations. Also, continuation of gender mainstreaming
was reinforced in the process of programming the Fourth Development Plan of
the government; consequently more was allocated to improve women’s status in the
country. Presence of these Articles in the Fourth Plan caused to sustainable implementation
and follow up of gender programs.
2. Membership of the Center for Women’s Participation in Supreme Councils of
Institutional Mechanisms for the Advancement of Women
102
National Beijing+10 Report ofthe Communication Network of
Women's NGOs of the I.R.I
Employment, Youth, Vocational and Technical Training, Social Commission and
also Cultural Commission of the Government resulted to the fact that women’s
issues are taken into account in high rank decision making and supreme levels of
the country. Membership of the Center for Women’s Participation in these councils
is to increase the consideration of the gender perspective in programmes.
Gender Disaggregated Data
H.3 GENERATEAND DISSEMINATE GENDER-DISAGGREGATED DATA
AND INFORMATION FOR PLANNING AND EVALUATION
Planning and programming on women’s issues is not only dependant on presence
of fundamental mechanisms or gender sensitive people who are able to do gender
analysis in governmental structures. Since, existence of gender sensitive and segregated
statistics and data and its continuous distribution is one of the main bases of
mainstreaming gender programs. Moreover, formation of programming organizations
for women on one hand and formation of women’s research centers in universities,
gender segregated data has become a necessity. The main source of information
and statistic distribution of the country is “Iran Statistical Center” that is
involved in provisions to prepare sex segregated statistics and conducting research
in indicating gender sensitive indicators. International organization like UNPFA is
cooperating with government on a project to gather, distribute and using gender sensitive
and sex segregated data.
Also, organizations involved and dealing with women’s issues such as the Social
and Cultural Council of Women, the Center for Women’s Participation and
women’s departments in ministries have had innovations in gathering sex segregated
and gender sensitive data especially in preparing qualitative statistics that has
brought achievements upon follow ups of women’s issues in higher ranks. In this
regard the budget of the center increased and the number of employees and experts
had a quantitative growth.
Social and Cultural Council of Women
Social and Cultural Council of Women in the frame of the Supreme Council of the
Cultural Revolution as one of its sub-group councils stated its activities in 1987 following
the objective of policy-making and conducting research over cultural and
social issues of women including representatives of three major authorities, governmental
organizations and institutions. The main activity of the Social and Cultural
Council of Women is establishing information and statistic center of women in 2000
and preparing mandate of rights and women’s responsibilities in the Islamic
Republic of Iran. This council has conducted researches at different levels such as
Assessment of Women’s Psychological and Physical Health, Assessment of Women
Graduates Occupation Conditions and its relevance to their education, Assessing
level of participation and responsibilities of family members and ways of reinforcing
it.
Gender Focal Points in Governmental Structures
In 1991, in most of the Ministries, an advisor to the minister for women’s affairs
was appointed and organizations were established focusing on women’s issues.
Also, in the structure of State Management and Planning Organization, working
groups of women and youth has been formed. These focal points have been estab-
Institutional Mechanisms for the Advancement of Women
103
National Beijing+10 Report ofthe Communication Network of
Women's NGOs of the I.R.I
lished in the structure of governor general’s office at provincial level. According to
the agenda, all women commissions in all governor general’s offices were formed
in 1990 and gradually these commissions were also formed in governor’s office and
women’s cultural and social organizations were later established in 1992 to 1994 in
different countries. Later, for more coordination, in 1995, a department was formed
in the Ministry of Interior named as the Bureau of Women’s Affairs with fourteen
official posts. During the next years up to 2000, the commissions handed over their
activities to women and youth work groups. Now, office of women’s affairs is
active in all provinces having a defined agenda. Meanwhile, women’s socio-cultural
centers are in the process of becoming independent and in the planning and development
council of each province, a women and youth’s work group is active in
planning process of the province. In other words, inclusion of these focal points in
governmental structures has paved the way for priorities of women’s issues to be
included in local planning.
Gender Sensitive Training for Governmental Managers
The third indicator is gender sensitive training to governmental authorities. In this
regard, office of women’s affairs in collaboration with NGOs and some training
organization has started training activities since 1993 in many ministries.
Meanwhile, the Center for Women’s Participation in collaboration of UNFPA has
started a five-year plan for holding gender sensitive training for government authorities
in five different areas of the country.
Institutional Activities of the Parliament and the State Expediency Council
Institutional activities are of great importance in Islamic Parliament Council.
During the fifth Islamic Parliament Council, commissions of women, family and
youth were formed. In sixth and seventh it changed to women’s fraction to submit
proposals regarding women’s issues. Aspecial committee for women and youth was
established at 1997 in the State Expediency Council, which has influenced the
changes in legislating processes in the county, to prepare and give comments over
general policies of the government and act as a counselor to solve women and
youths’ problems.
Mainstreaming Gender Perspectives
H.2 INTEGRATE GENDER PERSPECTIVES IN LEGISLATION, PUBLIC
POLICIES, PROGRAMMES AND PROJECTS
The following are two main results of the activities of the Center for Women’s
Participation during these years:
Continuation of gender mainstreaming in development plans- it is worth mentioning
that the development plans of Iran are five-year plans and the Fourth Five-Year
Development Plan will start in March 2005. Gender perspective was included in
Article 158 of Third Development Plan that started at 2000 and continued till 2005.
The important point is that women entered the framework of fundamental mechanisms
in development planning procedures. Although, gender perspective emerged
just as an Article in development plans, considering the budget mechanisms and
implementation system it gained great importance. This article promoted the budget
for women’s social and cultural participation (gender budgeting) and the Center
for Women’s Participation reached an agreement with the State Management and
Institutional Mechanisms for the Advancement of Women
104
National Beijing+10 Report ofCommunication Network of Women's NGOs
of the Islamic Republic of Iran
Planning Organization, it was allocated to relevant organization and this center
monitored the costs. The main indicator in this practice is filling the gap of access
for women to implementing organization’s facilities and also the possibility of utilizing
women’s capacities to emphasize on skills learning, proper programs for free
time, increasing occupation opportunities, expanding legal and judicial counseling
services and empowerment of women NGOs. Although a national, practical and
subtle evaluation of the activities during the five years of third plan and preparing
a report was difficult but there should be gender indications, output and final impact
evaluation and stability of the projects considering the objectives and indicators of
the third development plan of the country. We can refer to center of documentation
and information of the Social and Cultural Council of Women (there is a web site),
women’s information center related to women’s participation center, annual reports
of the Ministry of Education regarding education status of girls and status of women
working in Ministries and information site of women’s affairs office of the Ministry
of Interior as examples.
Government’s Actions
Formation of the Bureau for Women’s Affair which later on changed to the Center
for Women’s Participation is a policy making organization in the governments so
that the director of the center is bother consoler to the president regarding women’s
issues and is continually present in government board meetings and is also member
of some of supreme councils of planning.
Increasing activities of the Social and Cultural Council of Women as a policy making
organization in the Supreme Council of the Cultural Revolution and especially
approval of legal mandate and responsibilities of women and also approval of policies
of establishment, reinforcement and promotion of family in Islamic structure.
Approval of third economic, social and cultural development plan of the country
and its special focus on empowerment programs for NGOs which increased the
number of women NGOs.
Continuation of applying gender mainstreaming in provisions of five year plans of
the country (especially third and fourth plans of the country).
Formation of Women’s Department since 1991 in the Ministry of Interior and
women’s commissions at provincial level and in most ministries, formation of different
women organizations in the Parliament (women commission and then
women’s fraction), formation of women and youth work groups in planning and
development councils of provinces, women and youths’ committee in state expediency
council.
Formation of gender network in four provinces and one region due to the common
project of UNFPAand the Center for Women’s Participation containing members of
governmental and non-governmental organizations to promote the capabilities of its
members in utilizing gender perspective and attitudes in planning.
Women’s NGOs Activities
Process of NGO participation in reinforcing the fundamental mechanisms
according to the report containing activities of 230 women NGOs, focuses on
capacity building to institutionalize its organization. Also, target group of most
of the services have been rural women and disadvantaged and vulnerable levels
of the society.
Institutional Mechanisms for the Advancement of Women
105
National Beijing+10 Report ofthe Communication Network of
Women's NGOs of the I.R.I
Holding conferences to stabilize NGOs in the Third and Fourth Development Plan
of the country
Holding training workshops for empowerment of women for their active participation
in civil society
Research association for assessing the role of NGOs in delivering services to earthquake
stricken city of Bam
Formation and establishment of women and youth NGOs in different cities to
expand the dimension of the activities at local level and stabilize the organizations
Creating networks among organizations to increase communication and exchange
of experience
Running the NGO Training Center for capacity building of NGOs
Gaining consoler status to the United Nations and membership in international federations-
at the moment 11 NGO have consoler status to the socio-economic council
of the United Nations
Establishing branches in the provinces and expanding activities at local levels
Establishing Rural Women Corporations
Establishing special counseling centers for women
Creating training centers for orphan girls in deprived and rural areas
Providing space for NGOs to help them to continue their activities
Membership of NGOs in provincial work groups
Meeting directors of provinces to introduce capable women for managerial posts
Fundamental mechanisms for women’s development are one of the main issues and
commitments of the government. But NGOs play a crucial role in the fundamental
process to facilitate planning, implementation and decentralized monitoring of gender
main streaming processes. Practice and implementation of this responsibility
needs gender focus in planning the projects for service delivery and other projects.
Also, it is necessary to train the staff members of women NGOs regarding gender
issues and also on the issue of NGOs entry to the process of gender mainstreaming.
Focus of most of the women NGOs on reinforcing inter organization capacities and
lack of coverage of target groups in the process of gender mainstreaming shows that
most of these NGOs didn’t have active, determinant and influential over the government
and other governmental organizations and they are mostly beneficiaries of
this process. While only a small portion of women NGOs have a long history of
activity to improve women’s status and are the main consolers of the government
and have actively participated in providing training, gender literature, monitoring of
gender programs, research and evaluating government’s activities.
However, the number of women NGOs holding and consultant status is not enough
to be able to influence the international process. It is necessary for women organizations
active at national level to gain such status in the socio-economic council of
the United Nations.
CNWN Activities
The following have been done to promote working capacities of the network:
Requesting for consultative status and women’s organizations presence as observers
in social issues to the Organization of the Islamic Countries
Planning and action to gain consultant status in policy making, programming and
Institutional Mechanisms for the Advancement of Women
106
National Beijing+10 Report ofthe Communication Network of
Women's NGOs of the I.R.I
implementing organizations of the country
Purchasing a building for permanent settlement of the secretariat of the network
Planning and action to establish NGO system organization in the Islamic Republic
of Iran
Planning and action to prepare the national mandate of women NGOs in the Islamic
Republic of Iran
Quantitative promotion of network members form 70 to 200 women NGOs
Consulting the Statistical Center of Iran for gathering information and statistics of
NGOs quantitative situation in the country which was approved by the statistic
supreme council to be implemented every two year and define gender sensitive indicators
for two groups of men and women to be included in the census of 2006.
Fourth National Development Plan
Part of the Plan that is related to the issue is as follows:
Government is committed to take following actions to reinforce women’s role in the
society and providing opportunities and expansion of women’s participation in the
country:
A. Providing, approving and implementing General Plan of Developing Women’s
Participation including reviewing rules and regulations, especially civil law, promoting
women’s skills according to their social needs and technology evolutions,
identifying and increasing investing bodies in occupational opportunities, attention
to the gender composition of work forces, promoting life quality and promoting
believes regarding competence of women.
B. Preparing and submitting bills regarding the issue of stabilizing family life to be
approved in competent assemblies.
C. Provisions and legal measures to eliminate violence against women.
D. Submitting the bill of establishment and expansion of NGOs, CBOs and
women’s organization to the Parliament.
Note: all implementing organization are committed to foresee the budget needed to
implement their legal duties regarding this article that is related to their legal duties
in the annual budget bills and coordinate for further actions with Women’s
Participation Center.
Challenges and Constraints
These mechanisms stay in the margins of governmental structure and limited to
consultation level and relevant authorities do not have authorizations which makes
them inactive to implement decisions regarding women.
Lack of similar models of gender mainstreaming development in implementing
organizations and lack of accordance of some of these gender mainstreaming programs
with development conditions and situation of the country.
Lack of gender budget to meet the needs of the provinces especially in deprived
provinces.
Those involved in planning and programming lack gender perspectives in their policies,
programs and gender analysis of their outputs.
Lack of defined and transparent mechanisms to promote gender justice.
Insufficient use of monitoring capacities in governmental structures regarding gender
mainstreaming in the organizations.
Lack of a specific definition for “gender” in provision, distribution and utilization
Institutional Mechanisms for the Advancement of Women
107
National Beijing+10 Report ofthe Communication Network of
Women's NGOs of the I.R.I
of statistics and lack of definitions and methods for gathering inputs to assess poverty,
health and human rights among women and men including their access to
resources and lack of gender analysis in statistic usages.
Lack of inputs regarding wages especially in agriculture, livelihood agriculture and
other production activities out of working market due to lack of identification of
women’s economic services and unequal division of wages among men and women.
Recommendation to the Government
Creating a powerful and unified gender structure like a national organization (such
as Commission of gender equality) in the highest governmental rank which will
have enough authority to coordinate the programs of three leading powers of the
country and have legal support in monitoring the activities of these organizations in
gender mainstreaming.
Allocation of enough resources and power and competence to influence the policies
and reviewing laws.
Capacity of fundamental mechanisms in supporting, communication, coordination
and monitoring the implementation process.
Establishing methods to enable fundamental mechanisms to gather information
regarding policies in the first stages and necessity of reviewing these policies continuously.
Promoting gender perspectives among government implementing authorities on
methods of spending gender budgets and necessity of capacity building and their
empowerment on policy making, programming and prioritizing methods for women
issues.
Reinforcing monitoring systems over gender budgets and information distribution
methodologies to beneficiaries to participate in local gender programming.
Priorities on women issues have been settled considering the 30228 credits for
social and cultural participation and it seems that this has been effective in directing
and concentrating credits. It is recommended that instead of focusing on prioritizing,
trust local needs and stick to the prioritizing methodologies offered by state
management and programming organization.
Reinforcing constant reporting on efforts to legislature authorities to generalize
gender issues.
Cooperation with Parliamentarians and state expediency council to achieve gender
perspective in all laws and policies.
Achievement and expansion of collaborations with relevant governmental organizations,
women’s research center, university centers, private sector, media, NGOs
especially civil society activists by national organization for women’s development.
Promoting activities focusing on reforming laws including women’s status in the
family, employment, social services, tax, equal education opportunities by national
organization for women’s development.
Reinforcing direct links with national, regional and international delegations.
Promoting participation of women’s study center of the university and governmental
and non governmental research centers to test indicators and research methodologies
needed to reinforce gender analysis and monitoring and evaluation of gender
mainstreaming processes.
Promotion of active actors in government, private and NGO sectors to work regarding
gender justice among men and women.
Indicating women’s services in the process of development including paid and
Institutional Mechanisms for the Advancement of Women
108
National Beijing+10 Report ofthe Communication Network of
Women's NGOs of the I.R.I
unpaid services in policies and economic programming.
Recommendation to Women’s NGOs
Increasing involvement of NGOs in fundamental processes to facilitate planning,
implementation and decentralized monitoring over gender mainstreaming processes.
Reinforcing participatory activities to bring gender justice and other issues upon.
Providing consultation to legislatures to consider gender perspective in the policies
and programs.
Participation in testing indicators and essential methods to reinforce gender analysis
in monitoring and evaluating gender mainstreaming.
Gender assessment of poverty of women, women human rights, women’s reproductive
health and access to resources.
Conducting qualitative and quantitative research over women’s participation in
power and influence in the society such as number of men and women occupying
higher posts in decision making in private and public sectors.
Extensive activity to advocate gender mainstreaming especially gender budgeting
in the country.
Necessity of increasing the number of active researchers in the civil society with
gender perspectives to consult the government.
Conclusion
During the last ten years, women have been able to enter macro management systems
and gradually create institutional mechanisms for gender mainstreaming.
Existence of two mechanisms: the Social and Cultural Council for Women and the
Center for Women’s Participation created good changes to the benefit of women.
The main indicators that exist to evaluate institutional mechanisms in the country
show the achievements in this regard. Now, there is a national system for women’s
achievement in the country and in both mechanisms efforts have been toward
improving women’s situation. The last effort of women’s socio-cultural council was
providing the Charter of Right and Responsibilities of Women in the Islamic
Republic of Iran and the Center for Women’s Participation presented general system
of women’s participation and general legal system of women and have been
involved in planning process of the government through influencing third and
fourth national government plan. During the last four years there has been gender
focus centers in different areas of the country. All provinces have a consultant to
governor’s office for women’s affairs. The priorities of women’s issues is covered
by the credit of 30228 for women’s social and cultural participation and it seems
that this has been effective in directing credits to the benefit of women. Moreover,
in different ministries, women’s department has created changes in the fields of
women’s participation especially in agriculture and economy. In a general
overview, opportunities have been created gender mainstreaming.
Institutional Mechanisms for the Advancement of Women
109
National Beijing+10 Report ofthe Communication Network of
Women's NGOs of the I.R.I
Institutional Mechanisms for the Advancement of Women
110
National Beijing+10 Report ofthe Communication Network of
Women's NGOs of the I.R.I